Appendices
Appendix A: Glossary
Accounts receivable/debt — amounts claimed by the Province against debtors.
Tax assessments — a written notice from government of an amount owed to the Province. This notice represents monies that should have been remitted or paid to the Province, as well as, any penalty or interest charges imposed by the Province.
Audit and review — an examination of an individual’s or business’ financial records or accounts to ensure that the amounts owed have been collected and remitted, or paid as required. This can vary from the review of grants, tax expenditure and exemptions and compliance with legislation, to the examination of financial records and legal documents.
Billing — the act of notifying an individual or business of an amount owed to the Province.
Collections — remedial actions employed by the Province to effect a payment from an individual or business on an overdue account receivable.
Incremental revenue — monies identified by, or remitted in response to, audit and enforcement activities.
Overdue — an account receivable for which no monies have been remitted and is considered overdue according to the legislation at issue.
Penalty — a fine imposed for an offence against the legislation at issue (most commonly assessed for non-remittance of taxes).
Recoveries — monies recovered in the course of administering accounts receivable.
Remittance — the payment of monies to meet a financial obligation.
Refund — return of monies remitted in error or in excess of an account receivable.
Revenue — all monies received to meet financial obligations or identified as owed to the Province.
Small business — a small business has fewer than 50 employees or is operated by a person who is self-employed without paid help.
Tax expenditure — the reduction in tax revenues that results when government programs or benefits are delivered through the tax system rather than reported as budgetary expenditures. Tax expenditures are usually made by offering special tax rates, exemptions or tax credits to program beneficiaries.
Transaction — the act of processing a cheque or scanable coupon for the purpose of applying payment to an account receivable.
Voluntary compliance — when taxpayers meet their financial obligations without requiring the Province to effect payment.
Appendix B: Legislation Administered by the Ministry
The Minister of Small Business and Revenue and Minister Responsible for Regulatory Reform is charged with the administration
of the following enactments, presented alphabetically.
Assessment Act Assessment Authority Act Corporation Capital Tax Act Esquimalt and Nanaimo Railway Belt Tax Act Home Owner Grant Act Hotel Room Tax Act Income Tax Act Indian Self Government Enabling Act Insurance Premium Tax Act International Financial Activity Act Land Tax Deferment Act Logging Tax Act |
![]() |
Medicare Protection Act Mining Tax Act Motor Fuel Tax Act Petroleum and Natural Gas Act Property Transfer Tax Act Sechelt Indian Government District Home Owner Grant Act Social Service Tax Act Taxation (Rural Area) Act Tobacco Tax Act Tourism Accommodation (Assessment Relief) Act |
The Minister of Small Business and Revenue and Minister Responsible for Regulatory Reform is charged with the administration
of the following enactments, in areas related to revenue management processes only.
Forest Act Forest and Range Practices Act Forest Practices Code of British Columbia Act Forest Stand Management Fund Act Ministry of Forests Act Mineral Land Tax Act Mineral Tax Act | ![]() |
Petroleum and Natural Gas Act Range Act School Act South Moresby Implementation Account Act Wildfire Act |
Appendix C: British Columbia/Canada Revenue
Agency
Work Plan Summary
The Ministry of Small Business and Revenue represents British Columbia in its relationship with the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) with respect to the taxation statutes CRA administers on behalf of the province. Working with the ministry, CRA identifies and collects personal and corporate income taxes that help support the provision of vital provincial programs such as health care, education and transportation.
The ministry is currently working with CRA to identify opportunities to further develop and strengthen its ongoing partnership and collaborative initiatives with respect to tax administration to ensure that all revenue due to the province is identified and received by the province. This work is supported by a detailed British Columbia Work Plan developed jointly by the ministry and CRA. The work plan identifies both ongoing and one-time initiatives, accountabilities and, where appropriate, timelines and performance measures. A high level summary of key work plan objectives includes:
- A variety of initiatives to ensure the province receives an accurate allocation of the identified tax liability.
- The development of a comprehensive Service Management Framework and associated Service Level Agreements. This work will more accurately reflect British Columbia’s ongoing relationship with CRA, support the effective delivery of British Columbia’s income taxation programs and will include performance measures to determine CRA’s accountability for delivery of these programs.
- Continued collaboration between the ministry and CRA to identify and implement solutions to various administrative, reporting, data management and information sharing issues to support enhanced administration of British Columbia’s taxation programs.
- Completion of a Framework for a Collaborative Relationship Agreement outlining the guiding principles governing the CRA’s administration of the province’s income taxation programs.
- Establishing a process to ensure provincial tax administration priorities and issues are included in the strategic planning process.
- Continued collaborative efforts to address non-compliance with tax obligations to promote fairness and equity by leveling the playing field for the individuals and businesses that are meeting their financial obligations voluntarily.
- Improving customer service by providing simplified, streamlined audit processes through increased concurrent federal and provincial audit activities.
Appendix D: Ministry Organizational Structure and Key Responsibilities
Appendix E: Taxpayer Fairness and Service Code —
Service Standards
Twelve service standards have been identified to monitor the ministry’s progress in meeting the commitments set out in the Taxpayer Fairness and Service Code. This first set of standards focuses on customer transactions, letting customers know what to expect from the ministry when interacting with staff. The established standards focus on the timeliness and accessibility of service. Over time, the ministry will add to and improve its service standards based on consultation with the small business community and feedback from taxpayers.
Prior to determining the ministry’s service standards, research was conducted to review similar work in local and out-of-country jurisdictions. The ministry did not adopt specific service standards from other jurisdictions due to differences in business processes, technology and level of resources applied, but made efforts to include common service aspects. For example, standards were selected for inquiries, registrations, refunds, correspondence, audits and appeals. Based on this research, service standards were developed in partnership with several small business organizations to reflect the standards the small business community felt were most important to them.
The following table lists the service standards and identifies the targets established for each service standard. The 2006/07 targets reflect baseline data available for nine of the twelve service standards, with future years’ targets reflecting the ministry’s commitment to maintaining high levels of service and continuous improvement. Baselines for the remaining three service standards will be established in 2006/07.
The ministry will monitor performance using existing ministry business information systems. A service standard will be considered to ‘be met’ if, over the twelve months of the fiscal year, the performance meets or exceeds the established target.
Service Standards1 | 2006/07 Target |
2007/08 Target |
2008/09 Target |
---|---|---|---|
Respond to general email inquiries regarding sales, hotel, fuel and tobacco tax sent to CTBTaxQuestions@gov.bc.ca within 2 business days of receiving all of the necessary information. | Establish baseline in 2006/07 | TBD | TBD |
Respond to complex email inquiries and written rulings on sales, hotel, fuel or tobacco tax issues within 20 business days of receiving all of the necessary information. | 77% | 80% | 82% |
Register sales and hotel tax accounts within 2 business days of receiving all of the necessary information. | 90% | 90%2 | 90%2 |
Respond to requests to confirm if any sales or hotel taxes are owed by the business to be bought within 5 business days of receiving all of the necessary information. | 85% | 85%2 | 85%2 |
Process sales, hotel, fuel or tobacco tax refunds within 30 calendar days of receiving all of the necessary information. | 85% | TBD3 | TBD3 |
Respond to correspondence sent to the Minister, Deputy Minister and Assistant Deputy Minister within 14 business days of receipt. | Establish baseline in 2006/07 | TBD | TBD |
Receive email anytime and be accessible by telephone from 8:30 am to 4:30 pm., Monday through Friday (except holidays). | 100% | 100% | 100% |
Provide walk-in service at the ministry’s public offices in Victoria and Vancouver from 8:30 am to 4:30 pm., Monday through Friday (except holidays). | 100% | 100% | 100% |
Have helpful information about the ministry’s programs available on the website 24 hours a day, every day. | 99.7%4 | 99.7%4 | 99.7%4 |
Review the audit process and Taxpayer Fairness and Service Code rights before starting an audit at the place of business or representative’s office. | 100% | 100% | 100% |
Deputy Minister information reviews Provide written decision within 30 business days of receiving all of the necessary information and where required, the opinion of an objective third party. | Establish baseline In 2006/07 | TBD | TBD |
Provide a written decision on issues appealed to the minister within the average annual response time. | 5 months | 4.5 months | 4.5 months |
1 | The statement in the service standards dealing with Service BC-Government Agents was provided to inform customers that information about ministry programs is available from Service BC. This was not included in the above list as the ministry is not accountable for service provided by Service BC, but the ministry will ensure they have the information required to fulfill this commitment. |
2 | A significant increase in account registrations and clearances are anticipated due to the upcoming 2010 Olympic and Paralympic Winter Games in Vancouver. |
3 | The Consumer Taxation Programs Branch (a key contributor to the standard) is currently streamlining its refund process to improve response times. It is anticipated that future targets will be set higher. |
4 | Based on a Common Information Technology Services standard of 24/7 service, which excludes scheduled downtime for system maintenance on Sundays between 6:00 a.m. and 9:00 a.m. |
Appendix F: Changes to Goals, Objectives, Performance Measures and Targets
Since the publication of the 2005/06–2007/08 Service Plan Update, the ministry has undertaken a review of its goals, objectives and performance measures. The ministry has made changes that better focus the plan on:
- the ministry’s service to the public;
- the key outcomes expected from ministry activities; and
- the few critical aspects of the ministry’s performance of interest to the public, stakeholders and Members of the Legislative Assembly.
These changes are intended to improve service planning and performance reporting, and support increased accountability.
In summary, the ministry has moved from six goals to four. The following table provides the details of the changes made to goal statements and the resulting changes to the objectives aligned with these goals. There has been no significant change in strategic direction.
Former Goals, Objectives, Strategies and Performance Measures | Status | New Goals, Objectives, Strategies and Performance Measures | Reason for Change |
---|---|---|---|
Goal: Small business development. | Unchanged | ![]() ![]() |
|
Objective: Facilitate economic opportunities for small business. | Unchanged | ||
Goal: A regulatory climate that supports economic and business competitiveness. | Reworded | Goal: A streamlined and simplified regulatory environment. | More clearly identifies ministry accountability in the area of regulatory reform. |
Objective: Improve regulatory quality. | Unchanged | ![]() ![]() |
|
Objective: Minimize the regulatory burden on British Columbians. | Removed | ![]() |
Now captured as a strategy |
Goal: Maximize voluntary compliance. | ![]() ![]() |
Goal: Amounts owed to government are paid.![]() |
Former goals were consolidated and reworded. The new goal better reflects the outcome expected from the ministry’s tax administration
and revenue management activities.![]() |
Goal: Collection of all outstanding amounts owed to British Columbians. | |||
Objective: Individuals and businesses understand their entitlements and obligations, and pay the correct amount on time. | Unchanged | ![]() |
|
Objective: British Columbians receive the revenue they are due. | Reworded![]() |
Objective: The Province receives the outstanding amounts due.![]() |
Former objectives were consolidated and reworded. The new objective more concisely captures the outcome expected from the
ministry’s audit, compliance and debt collection activities.![]() |
Objective: British Columbians receive the debt recoveries they are due. | |||
Objective: Maximize use of new electronic technologies to facilitate ease of transactions. | Maintained as a Strategy | ![]() |
Now captured as a strategy. |
Goal: Continuous performance improvement and accountability. | Reworded | Goal: Service that meets the needs of customers, stakeholders and partners. | The new goal clarifies the ministry’s commitment to service excellence. The continuous improvement aspect of the former goal is captured in strategies. |
Goal: Fair, efficient and equitable administration that meets customers’ needs. | Maintained as an Objective | Objective: Fair and efficient administration, and quality service. | New objective reflects the ministry’s commitment to service excellence. |
Objective: Improve the tax and property assessment appeals process for administrative fairness and due process. | Maintained as strategies![]() |
![]() ![]() |
Now captured as strategies and, where appropriate, in performance measures.![]() |
Objective: Continuously improve, streamline and simplify work processes. |
A summary of changes to the ministry’s performance measures is provided below. Measures were removed from the Service Plan where a better performance measure has been identified and where the measure is focused on internal administrative matters that are primarily of ministry interest. Those measures removed from the Service Plan that continue to be of importance to the ministry will be monitored internally as part of a suite of measures the ministry uses to support decision-making. However, all measures included in the ministry’s 2005/06–2007/08 Service Plan Update will be reported in the ministry’s 2005/06 Service Plan Report.
Former Performance Measures (2005/06–07/08 Service Plan Update) | Status | New Performance Measures | Reason for Change |
---|---|---|---|
Established a small business roundtable. | Reworded | Implement a small business strategy | The new measure more accurately tracks performance towards the objective and measures the outcome expected from a key initiative underway in the ministry. |
Regulatory quality — Percentage of new legislation and regulations meeting regulatory reform criteria. | Removed | ![]() |
This measure will be reported internally. |
Government-wide regulatory requirements. | Unchanged | ![]() ![]() |
|
Requirements to access government programs and services, and comply with regulations. | New | ![]() |
This new performance measure will track government-wide efforts to streamline and simplify access to government programs and services, and reduce the steps required to comply with regulations. The measure will be developed and a baseline established in 2006/07. Performance reporting will begin in 2007/08. |
Percentage of revenue administered without intervention. | Replace | Percentage of identified revenue collected. | Replaced with a measure that more accurately reports on the ministry’s success in collecting amounts owed to government. |
Percentage of revenue received through electronic payments. | Removed | ![]() |
This measure will be reported internally. |
Percentage of on-time tax payments. | Unchanged | ![]() ![]() |
|
Incremental revenue. | Reworded | Percentage of incremental revenue target achieved. | The measure presents both the percentage of the revenue target to be achieved and the dollar value as outlined under the Balanced Budget Ministerial Accountability Act. |
Number of audits and reviews performed. | Unchanged | ![]() ![]() |
|
Average tax assessment per audit position. | Unchanged | ![]() ![]() |
|
Debt collections. | Replaced with new measure![]() |
Percentage of overdue accounts collected.![]() |
The new measure demonstrates the ministry’s success in managing the accounts receivable portfolio. The ministry will establish
a baseline and targets in 2006/07 and begin reporting on performance in 2007/08. ![]() |
Percentage of total government accounts receivable more than 90 days overdue. | |||
Elapsed time from receipt of tax appeal to final decision. | Unchanged | ![]() ![]() |
|
Receipt to deposit turnaround time. | Removed | ![]() |
This measure will be reported internally. |
Cost per transaction. | Removed | ![]() |
The ministry has transitioned payment/transaction processing and non-tax debt collection services to a private sector service provider. These are two of the services provided to the ministry by the service provider using new business processes and technologies. The terms of the contract provide payment on a consolidated, transformed suite of services, not on a service by service basis. |
Average recovery per tax collection position. | Removed | ![]() |
|
Cost to collect $1 of debt. | Removed | ![]() |
|
Success in meeting service standards. | New | ![]() |
This new measure will report on the ministry’s performance in meeting the service standards detailed in the Taxpayer Fairness and Service Code. |